In her pre-tournament press conference this week, Michelle Wie said she was perfectly capable of making her own decisions and that ultimately, her decision to play this week, despite an injured wrist, was hers.
If that's the case, then Michelle really has only one decision to make right now, and that's to put the wrist on ice for awhile. Take a break, Michelle. Forget about the Ricoh Women's British Open next month and let your wrist and wounded psyche heal. Start thinking about your class schedule at Stanford, and not breaking 80.
For the second time this month, Wie WD'd from a tournament due to her injured left wrist, which she fractured back in January. Wie hit two shots on the 1st hole of the U.S. Open championship Saturday, her tenth hole of the day, and then told playing partners Christina Kim and Natalie Gulbis "no mas." At the time of her withdrawal, the 17-year-old was 6-over par on the day and 17-over par overall (through 27 holes), invoking memories of her controversial withdrawal at the Ginn Tribute hosted by Annika Sorenstam earlier this month. In that event, Wie was 14 over after 16 holes and dangerously close to shooting 88, which would have made her ineligible for the rest of the LPGA season. She didn't make any friends or alleviate the skepticism surrounding her withdrawal at Ginn by showing up the next day in Maryland to practice for the following week's McDonald's LPGA Championship.
In fairness to Wie, she definitely appeared to hurt the wrist Saturday. After "tweaking" it on the 17th tee, she drew a nasty lie in the rough off the fairway on 18. Upon hitting her second shot, she immediately pulled her left hand off the club and began shaking her wrist. Not long afterwards, a medic appeared and began massaging Wie's wrist as she walked toward the 18th green. About 10 minutes later, after snap-hooking her drive on No. 1, she withdrew.
Wie, looking teary-eyed at her press conference, says she will head to Florida in the coming days to have her wrist examined, and then will re-evaluate her playing schedule. As of now, the plan is to play the Evian Masters in France in late July, and then head to the British Open, which is being played at historic St Andrews for the first time. But for Wie, the decision should be easy. Skip them both.
It's obvious her wrist hasn't healed, and what's worse is her game has completely deteriorated to the point she has a hard time breaking 80. That can't do much for her confidence. Or her future. Wie hasn't broken par for 22 consecutive rounds. In five LPGA rounds this season, she's averaging 78 strokes. In addition to the 82 she shot in the first round on Thursday, she carded an 83 in the third round of the McDonald's LPGA Championship (which she finished dead last in, by 10 strokes).
It looked like she was headed for her third 80-plus score in four rounds before she withdrew Saturday.
These scores are shocking, considering Wie was tied for the lead after three rounds in this very same championship a year ago in Rhode Island, and at Cherry Hills two years ago. In four previous U.S. Open appearances, Wie's worst finish was a tie for 39th. A final-round 82 at Cherry Hills was the only real blip on her U.S. Open resume.
Wie still draws the largest galleries--there were at least 2,000 spectators following her on Saturday when there might have been 100 watching second-round leader Angela Park a few holes earlier--but most are there to see if she can break 80. They're not there to witness her once-tremendous talent. Golf Digest Senior Writer Ron Sirak called it the NASCAR-viewing mentality: People are watching Wie to see her wreck.
"It's really a shame," said Gary Gilchrist, who coached Wie between the ages of 12 and 14, when Wie first blossomed on the scene and came to be known as the Big Wie-sy. "They've taken her natural ability away. When she was 13, she was swinging beautifully, much better than she is now. It doesn't get much better than that. She's been hitting it poorly for a year now."
Wie left Gilchrist for David Leadbetter three years ago, and has been in high demand recently for analysis of Wie's swing as Leadbetter has been fairly mum about her struggles. Wie's swing is much more compact now than it used to be, says Gilchrist, and her tempo is quicker. Too quick, he says.
"Her full swing is three-quarters now," said Gilchrist, who coaches McDonald's LPGA champion Suzann Pettersen. "There's too much lift in her backswing and not enough body turn, so there's no time to hit the ball. It's very handsy. She needs to have more feel to her swing if she wants to get it back."
Wie is an amazing talent and the LPGA Tour, in particular, needs her back. But not this way. Not when she's struggling to break 80 and all the focus on her is negative. Whoever is making the decisions, whether it's really Michelle or it's her father, B.J., or someone else in the Wie camp, they need to start making better decisions right now. They can start by giving her some time off. If they don't, we might not see Wie at the top of the leaderboard again anytime soon at the U.S. Open, and that would be a shame.